Big Island or Kaua’i, Which is Better?

If you’re planning a trip to Hawaii, you might be torn between two of the most iconic islands: Big Island or Kaua’i. Both islands offer unique landscapes, incredible outdoor activities, and rich Hawaiian culture, but they each have distinct personalities. So, which island should you visit? Whether you’re into adventure, relaxation, or cultural experiences, this guide will help you decide between Big Island or Kaua’i.

I. Big Island or Kaua’i

1. The Big Island

The Big Island, officially called Hawaii Island, is the largest and most diverse of all the Hawaiian islands. Its vast size allows it to showcase nearly all of the world’s climates, from tropical rainforests to volcanic deserts. The island is a playground for outdoor enthusiasts with its active volcanoes, massive mountains, and unique black and green sand beaches. Big Island also offers various cultural experiences, from visiting coffee farms to learning about Hawaiian history at Pu’uhonua o Honaunau National Historical Park.

Highlights of Big Island:

• Volcanoes National Park: Home to one of the world’s most active volcanoes, Kilauea, this park allows you to hike over volcanic craters and even witness lava flows when active.
• Mauna Kea: The tallest mountain in the world when measured from its base on the ocean floor, it’s a prime spot for stargazing.
• Waipio Valley: Known for its breathtaking views and towering waterfalls, this valley is a slice of paradise that can be explored by foot or horseback.
• Black and green sand beaches: Punalu’u (black sand) and Papakolea (green sand) are unique beaches that offer stunning coastal scenery and great photo ops.
• Coffee farms in Kona: Tour local coffee farms and sample some of the world’s best coffee.

2. Kaua’i

Kaua’i, known as the “Garden Isle,” is famous for its lush greenery and natural beauty. It is the oldest of the Hawaiian islands and offers an unspoiled, tranquil experience. With fewer crowds and a slower pace of life, Kaua’i is ideal for travelers looking for a more laid back and intimate vacation. The island is characterized by its dramatic landscapes, including the towering cliffs of the Na Pali Coast and the stunning Waimea Canyon, often called the “Grand Canyon of the Pacific.”

Highlights of Kaua’i:

• Na Pali Coast: A 17 mile stretch of sheer cliffs, lush valleys, and pristine beaches, best explored by boat, helicopter, or hiking the famous Kalalau Trail.
• Waimea Canyon: A vibrant, colorful canyon that offers numerous trails and breathtaking views of the island’s unique geology.
• Hanalei Bay: A stunning bay with crystal clear waters and a charming small town atmosphere, perfect for paddleboarding or relaxing on the beach.
• Wailua Falls: One of Kaua’i’s most iconic waterfalls, offering a peaceful escape into nature.
• Secluded beaches: Kaua’i is home to some of Hawaii’s most remote and less crowded beaches, such as Polihale State Park and Secret Beach.

II. What island should you choose if you like…

1. Outdoor adventures

For thrill seekers and nature lovers, both islands offer incredible outdoor activities, but they have different strengths.

• On the Big Island, you’ll find a variety of landscapes perfect for adventure. You can hike across active volcanic craters in Volcanoes National Park, explore ancient lava tubes, and sometimes even see live lava flows. For a unique experience, head to Mauna Kea for some world class stargazing at nearly 14,000 feet above sea level. You can also take a challenging hike to the remote Waipio Valley, home to towering waterfalls and lush rainforests, or dive with manta rays at night one of the island’s most famous adventures. The Big Island’s diversity in climate zones makes every outdoor excursion feel like an entirely new experience.
• On Kaua’i, the adventure is more about its lush, green environment and rugged terrain. The island is famous for the dramatic Na Pali Coast, best explored by hiking the Kalalau Trail or taking a boat tour to see the towering cliffs and hidden beaches. For a different kind of challenge, hike through the breathtaking Waimea Canyon, known as the “Grand Canyon of the Pacific.” Kaua’i also offers excellent opportunities for kayaking on the Wailua River or ziplining through dense tropical forests. Kaua’i’s untamed nature makes it a paradise for hikers, paddlers, and eco adventurers.

2. Beaches

When it comes to beaches, both islands offer something special, but their appeal is different.

• Kaua’i is known for its classic Hawaiian beaches with long stretches of soft, white sand. Hanalei Bay is a top pick for its serene beauty and crescent shaped shoreline, perfect for swimming, paddleboarding, or just relaxing. Poipu Beach is family friendly with calm waters and excellent snorkeling. For those seeking more secluded spots, Tunnels Beach offers a peaceful atmosphere with fantastic snorkeling, while the remote Polihale State Park is perfect for a tranquil beach day with stunning views and almost no crowds.
• The Big Island, on the other hand, offers more diverse and unusual beaches. Punalu’u Beach, famous for its black sand, is a must see, especially if you’re lucky enough to spot the sea turtles that often sunbathe there. Another unique experience is the green sand at Papakolea Beach, one of the only four green sand beaches in the world. Though not as famous for its white sand, Hapuna Beach on the Big Island’s west coast is considered one of the best for swimming and sunbathing, with long stretches of soft sand and clear waters.

4. Volcanoes

If volcanoes are on your travel checklist, the Big Island is hands down the winner.

• It’s home to Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park, which features two of the world’s most active volcanoes: Kilauea and Mauna Loa. You can hike along the crater rims, explore vast lava fields, walk through lava tubes, and even during active times witness glowing lava. The Big Island’s volcanic landscape is truly unmatched and offers a one of a kind experience.
• Kaua’i, on the other hand, is much older geologically and doesn’t have any active volcanoes. However, the island’s lush, green mountains are the result of ancient volcanic activity, with beautiful remnants of volcanic craters like Mount Waialeale, one of the wettest places on earth. Kaua’i’s volcanic history has shaped its dramatic landscapes, but if live volcanoes are your interest, head to the Big Island.

5. Food, drinks, and nightlife

For foodies and those looking for a bit of nightlife, the islands differ quite a bit.

• The Big Island has a growing food scene, especially around the towns of Kona and Hilo, where you can find everything from local food trucks to upscale farm to table restaurants. The island is also famous for its Kona coffee farms, where you can tour and taste some of the best coffee in the world. The Big Island has more in the way of nightlife compared to Kaua’i, with bars and live music, particularly in the Kona area, but don’t expect a bustling club scene.
• Kaua’i offers a more laid back dining experience, with small, locally owned restaurants serving fresh seafood, poke, and tropical fruits. While you won’t find much nightlife on Kaua’i, you will discover a quiet charm, perfect for those who prefer evenings spent watching the sunset or enjoying a relaxing dinner by the beach. The island’s rural vibe adds to its peaceful atmosphere, so it’s a great place for those who want to unplug and enjoy local cuisine without the hustle of city life.

6. Variety/diversity

In terms of sheer variety, the Big Island offers the most diverse range of experiences.

• The island is so large that it encompasses almost every climate zone, from lush rainforests to dry volcanic deserts, snowy mountain peaks to sunny beaches. In one day, you could snorkel with tropical fish, hike on volcanic craters, and then relax at a cool coffee farm. This diversity makes the Big Island perfect for travelers who want a little bit of everything adventure, relaxation, culture, and geology all on one trip.
• Kaua’i, by contrast, is smaller and more consistent in its lush, tropical environment. It’s known as the “Garden Isle” for a reason, with verdant mountains, cascading waterfalls, and dense rainforests. While Kaua’i might not have the same geographical variety as the Big Island, it excels in its peaceful, untouched beauty, offering a more intimate and immersive experience in nature.

Ultimately, both islands have their strengths. If you’re looking for volcanic landscapes, adventure, and variety, the Big Island is your best bet. If you’re seeking pristine beaches, peaceful seclusion, and lush landscapes, Kaua’i is the perfect choice.

If you want an island that offers diverse landscapes, activities, and cultural experiences, the Big Island wins. You can go from a tropical rainforest to a desert like lava field in the same day, which makes exploring more exciting. Kaua’i, though incredibly beautiful, offers more consistency in its landscapes, with its dominant feature being its lush, green mountains.

III. Skip the Big Island, go to Kaua’i!

If you’re searching for a peaceful and beautiful Hawaiian escape, Kaua’i is the island for you. Often called the “Garden Isle,” Kaua’i is known for its stunning natural landscapes, including lush rainforests, dramatic cliffs, and pristine beaches. The island has a laid back vibe, making it ideal for those who want to relax and connect with nature.

One of the must see spots is the Na Pali Coast, famous for its breathtaking sea cliffs and secluded beaches that are only accessible by foot or boat. The Kalalau Trail offers an unforgettable hiking experience with jaw dropping views that reward your efforts. In addition, Kaua’i is less commercialized than the Big Island, which allows for a more authentic Hawaiian experience. You can explore charming towns like Hanalei and Kapa’a, where you’ll find local art galleries, farmers’ markets, and family run restaurants serving delicious island dishes.

For those who enjoy outdoor adventures, Kaua’i has plenty to offer. You can kayak on the Wailua River, hike to stunning waterfalls, or simply relax on some of the most beautiful beaches in Hawaii. If you’re looking for a serene getaway surrounded by natural beauty, Kaua’i is the perfect choice.

IV. Skip Kaua’i, go to the Big Island!

If your dream Hawaiian vacation includes diverse landscapes, exciting activities, and geological wonders, then the Big Island is the place for you. Known for its variety, the Big Island offers experiences that cater to all interests. For nature enthusiasts, Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park is a must visit. Here, you can see active volcanoes, explore lava tubes, and hike through unique volcanic landscapes.

The Big Island also provides numerous outdoor adventures, such as snorkeling in the clear waters of Kona, hiking to beautiful waterfalls in Akaka Falls State Park, or even stargazing atop Mauna Kea. If you love coffee, don’t miss touring the famous Kona coffee farms to sample some of the world’s best brews.

For food lovers, the Big Island has a vibrant culinary scene with a range of dining options, from food trucks to upscale restaurants. You’ll also find a few lively nightlife spots, especially in the Kona and Hilo areas.

If you want a vacation filled with beaches, mountains, cultural experiences, and a variety of outdoor activities, the Big Island is your best bet. Its diverse ecosystems and expansive landscapes ensure that every day offers new adventures and discoveries.

The Big Island is the ideal destination if you want more diversity in your activities and landscapes. From volcanic eruptions to snow capped mountains, black sand beaches to coffee farms, the Big Island offers an array of once in a lifetime experiences. Adventure seekers, geology buffs, and travelers looking for an island with a little bit of everything will feel right at home here.

V. Sample itineraries

Big Island Itinerary (3 Days)

• Day 1: Arrive in Kona, relax on Hapuna Beach, and enjoy a sunset dinner in Kona.
• Day 2: Explore Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park; hike to the Kilauea caldera and visit the Thomas A. Jaggar Museum. End the day with a scenic drive through Chain of Craters Road.
• Day 3: Visit the Mauna Kea Observatory for stargazing and take a tour of a Kona coffee farm before departure.

Kaua’i Itinerary (3 Days)

• Day 1: Arrive in Lihu’e, relax at Poipu Beach, and enjoy a traditional Hawaiian dinner at a local restaurant.
• Day 2: Take a boat tour along the Na Pali Coast for stunning views and snorkeling, or hike the Kalalau Trail for breathtaking scenery.
• Day 3: Visit Waimea Canyon for a scenic drive and short hikes; end your day at Hanalei Bay for a beautiful sunset.

Big Island Itinerary (5 Days)

• Day 1: Arrive in Kona, unwind at Kona Beaches, and explore local shops and restaurants.
• Day 2: Full day at Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park, hiking and experiencing volcanic landscapes.
• Day 3: Visit Mauna Kea for a sunrise experience; spend the afternoon exploring Hilo and its waterfalls, including Rainbow Falls.
• Day 4: Enjoy a snorkeling trip to Kealakekua Bay or Honaunau Bay; visit a local farmer’s market.
• Day 5: Relax at Hapuna Beach, and take a sunset cruise or enjoy local dining in Kona.

Kaua’i Itinerary (5 Days)

• Day 1: Arrive in Lihu’e, relax at Kalapaki Beach, and have dinner in Kapa’a.
• Day 2: Hike the Kalalau Trail along the Na Pali Coast; enjoy the views and explore the beaches.
• Day 3: Kayak on the Wailua River and visit Opaeka’a Falls; spend the afternoon at Lydgate Beach.
• Day 4: Explore Waimea Canyon; take short hikes and visit the lookout points.
• Day 5: Spend a day at Hanalei Bay; relax on the beach or enjoy water sports before departure.

Big Island Itinerary (7 Days)

• Day 1: Arrive in Kona, enjoy a beach day, and explore local shops.
• Day 2: Full day at Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park; visit both Kilauea and Mauna Loa.
• Day 3: Experience Mauna Kea for sunrise and explore Hilo, including Akaka Falls.
• Day 4: Snorkel at Kealakekua Bay, visit the Captain Cook Monument, and tour a coffee farm.
• Day 5: Visit Pu’uhonua o Honaunau National Historical Park and relax at Honaunau Beach.
• Day 6: Explore the Kona Coffee Belt and take a scenic drive along the Kona Coast.
• Day 7: Relax at Hapuna Beach, enjoy a spa day, and savor your last evening in Kona.

Kaua’i Itinerary (7 Days)

• Day 1: Arrive in Lihu’e, spend the afternoon at Kapa’a Beach, and enjoy local dining.
• Day 2: Take a boat tour of the Na Pali Coast; enjoy snorkeling and stunning views.
• Day 3: Hike Kalalau Trail for breathtaking vistas; explore the beaches along the way.
• Day 4: Visit Waimea Canyon; take in the views and hike to Canyon Lookout.
• Day 5: Spend the day at Hanalei Bay; enjoy swimming, paddleboarding, and beach relaxation.
• Day 6: Kayak on the Wailua River, visit Secret Falls, and have a picnic lunch.
• Day 7: Explore the Koloa Heritage Trail; relax at Poipu Beach and enjoy your final dinner in Kaua’i.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice between Big Island or Kaua’i comes down to your travel style and preferences. Both islands are spectacular in their own right, offering an unforgettable Hawaiian experience.

You can explore more about Hawaiian Islands, Hawaiian Shirts and Swim Trunks to discover their unique styles, history, and tips for choosing the right one for you. For a wide range of stylish options, visit Teroprints Shop, where you’ll find a collection of Swim Trunks and Hawaiian Shirts that are perfect for any occasion.

Don’t forget to stay connected with Teroprints on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook to keep up with our latest product releases and updates. Follow us for the newest trends and exclusive deals!

You can refer to the articles below for more helpful information:

• 30 Fun Facts about Hawaii
• Fun Things to Do on Vacation in Hawaii
• Best island to visit in Hawaii for the first time
• Pros and Cons of Living in Hawaii
• When is the Best Time to Visit Hawaii?

FAQs - Big Island or Kaua'i, Which is Better?